Explore My Research

My research focuses on migration, entrepreneurship, and political economy, with an emphasis on how institutions, policy environments, and economic incentives shape individual behavior and long-run development outcomes. Click a topic below to filter.

Migration Working Paper

Did the Syrian Refugee Crisis impact European economic freedom?

with Benjamin Powell

A prominent theoretical argument for immigration restrictions holds that large inflows from institutionally weaker countries could erode destination-country institutions. The Syrian refugee crisis offers the hardest possible test of this claim. Syria scored 4.53 on the Economic Freedom of the World (EFW) index while host countries scored approximately 8.0, a gap of 3.5 points. Refugees are less self-selected than voluntary migrants, and the scale was unprecedented: Germany absorbed over one million Syrians, Sweden took in 2.2% of its population.

We apply the synthetic control method to construct counterfactual EFW trajectories for Germany, Austria, and Sweden using a donor pool of 21 European countries where the Syrian-born population remained below 0.1%. The most notable donors are the United Kingdom (carrying 47% of Austria’s weight, 57% of Germany’s, and 39% of Sweden’s), the Czech Republic, France, Ireland, and Poland. We stack the three country-level analyses by aligning treatment years and averaging effects.

Stacked synthetic control: treated countries versus their synthetic counterfactual. Hover over the lines to see exact EFW values at each period.
Post-treatment effects with p-values. Hover over each bar to see the exact treatment effect and statistical significance.

The Syrian refugee surge did not meaningfully impact destination countries’ economic freedom. All post-treatment point estimates are negative but small; the largest gap is just 0.18 points in period 6, and most are statistically insignificant. Only period 6 reaches conventional significance (p = 0.05), with a joint p-value of 0.106. Sweden is the most striking case: despite having the highest refugee ratio and fastest naturalization pathway (58% naturalized by 2023), it shows no significant effects in any year. Results are robust to dropping the UK from the donor pool, using all pre-treatment lags without covariates, and adding immigrant stock as a covariate.

The Syrian case is particularly informative because the conditions for detecting erosion are maximally favorable. If institutional erosion were going to happen anywhere, it should have happened here. That it did not suggests that the mechanisms through which immigrants theoretically degrade institutions either do not operate or offset each other in practice.

Entrepreneurship Working Paper

Do corruption reforms spur entrepreneurship?

 

Pavlik et al. (2023) showed that sustained anti-corruption reforms cause economic growth, but through what channel? If corruption raises business costs through bribes and legal uncertainty, reducing it should encourage new ventures. This paper tests whether anti-corruption reforms boost entrepreneurship.

The key methodological challenge is staggered treatment adoption. Traditional two-way fixed effects DiD suffers from “forbidden comparisons” that bias estimates. This paper applies the Callaway and Sant’Anna (2021) DiD estimator, which computes group-time-specific treatment effects using only not-yet-treated or never-treated units as controls. Treatment is defined as a sustained 5-year improvement of more than 0.20 in the World Bank’s Control of Corruption index.

The analysis uses two complementary datasets: the World Bank Group Entrepreneurship Survey (formal firm registrations per 1,000 working-age people, 20 treated countries) and the Global Entrepreneurship Monitor (total, opportunity-driven, and necessity-driven TEA, 10 treated countries).

Event study: formal firm registrations after corruption reform
Event study for formal firm registrations (World Bank data): pre-treatment trends support parallel trends, but post-treatment effects are consistently negative and statistically insignificant.
Event study: total entrepreneurial activity after corruption reform
Event study for total early-stage entrepreneurial activity (GEM data): no discernible change in either direction after anti-corruption reform.

Anti-corruption reforms have no statistically significant effect on any measure of entrepreneurship. Formal registrations show a slight negative point estimate (ATT = −0.70, s.e. = 0.54). Total TEA is essentially flat (ATT = −0.51, s.e. = 1.42). Necessity-driven TEA shows the largest decline (−2.68) but remains insignificant. Pre-treatment periods consistently include zero, supporting parallel trends.

The divergence between formal data (slight decline) and GEM data (no change) suggests reforms may temporarily reshape the form of entrepreneurship, shifting activity between formal and informal sectors, without changing overall business creation rates. The growth benefits documented by Pavlik et al. must therefore flow through other channels: investment, human capital, or productivity improvements within existing firms.

Migration Published

Emigration and origin country economic institutions

with Benjamin Powell · Public Choice, 2025

Does emigration improve or erode economic institutions in origin countries? Drawing on public choice theory and Hirschman’s exit-voice framework, this paper identifies four channels: the absence channel (dissatisfied citizens leave, shifting the median voter toward the status quo), the prospect channel (governments reform to retain mobile citizens), the diaspora channel (emigrants transmit liberal norms back home), and the return channel (returnees bring human capital and new ideas). These channels predict an inverted-U: moderate emigration improves institutions, but extreme levels deplete human capital and civic participation.

We test this using panel data on emigration from 132 countries to 20 OECD destinations (1980-2010) and the Economic Freedom of the World (EFW) index. Specifications include two-way fixed effects, quadratic terms, skill-specific disaggregation, and instrumental variables.

Inverted-U relationship between emigrant stock and economic freedom change
Predicted total effect of emigrant stock on EFW change, showing the inverted-U relationship peaking near 20% of the population abroad.
Skill-specific emigration effects
Skill-specific effects: medium- and high-skill emigrant stocks drive institutional improvements, with high-skill effects never turning negative within the observed range.

The results confirm the inverted-U hypothesis. Emigrant stocks are positively and significantly associated with improvements in economic freedom, peaking at about 20% of the population abroad (a 0.90-point improvement on the 10-point EFW scale). Only above 47% does the effect turn negative, and only Guyana exceeds that threshold. This positive association is larger for countries with weaker initial institutions, consistent with the diaspora channel.

Medium- and high-skill emigrant stocks drive the result. High-skill emigration never turns negative within the observed range, suggesting persistent institutional spillovers. Contemporaneous flows show no significant effect, and IV estimates confirm that the negative OLS association for high-skill flows reflects reverse causality. The policy implication: allowing greater emigration from low-freedom countries could promote development through institutional improvement, a channel that adds to the already large estimated gains from freer migration.

Entrepreneurship Published

Property rights and entrepreneurship

Economic Affairs, 45(3), 509-521, 2025

The literature assumes a linear relationship between property rights and entrepreneurship. This paper challenges that assumption, proposing and testing a U-shaped (nonlinear) relationship. The logic: at low levels of property rights, necessity-driven entrepreneurship dominates as people start businesses out of survival. As institutions improve, formal jobs absorb this activity and total entrepreneurship declines. Beyond a threshold, opportunity-driven entrepreneurship accelerates and total activity rises again.

The empirical analysis uses panel data from the Global Entrepreneurship Monitor across 90 countries (2004-2018, 822 observations), paired with the Fraser Institute’s Legal System and Property Rights sub-index. The baseline is a random-effects panel regression of TEA on property rights and its square, controlling for GDP per capita, GDP growth, unemployment, and population growth.

U-shaped relationship between property rights and entrepreneurship
The U-shaped relationship: predicted TEA (solid curve) is driven by declining necessity entrepreneurship and rising opportunity entrepreneurship as property rights improve.

The results confirm the U-shape. The linear term is negative and significant (−5.590, p<0.01), the quadratic term positive and significant (+0.418, p<0.05), with a Wald test confirming the squared term matters (p = 0.011). The minimum occurs at a score of approximately 6.69, comparable to Chile. A purely linear specification yields an insignificant coefficient, demonstrating it misses the true relationship entirely.

Separate regressions reveal the mechanism: each additional point in property rights increases opportunity entrepreneurship by 0.0432 pp (p<0.01) while decreasing necessity entrepreneurship by 0.0142 pp (p<0.01). The gain in opportunity ventures is more than three times the decline in necessity ventures. Results are robust to using the World Bank’s Rule of Law index instead.

The policy implication: policymakers should not be discouraged if modest institutional improvements do not immediately produce a surge in business creation. The initial decline reflects a healthy transition away from survivalist informality. The payoff comes with sustained reform past the trough.

Fiscal & Monetary Policy Working Paper

Debt Constraints in Emerging Economies: Synthetic Control Evidence from Guatemala

 

Following a severe macroeconomic crisis in the 1980s (inflation at 60%, exchange rate collapse), Guatemala adopted two landmark fiscal rules: a 1991 Monetary Board resolution limiting central bank lending to the government, and a 1993 constitutional amendment outright prohibiting it. Did these rules produce genuine fiscal discipline?

The paper uses the synthetic control method with 17 donor countries from Latin America, Asia, and Africa (1970-2004). The synthetic Guatemala is composed of Belize (29%), El Salvador (23%), Bangladesh (22%), Paraguay (21%), and Uganda (5%), achieving strong pre-treatment fit (RMSPE = 3.87).

Guatemala’s actual debt-to-GDP versus its synthetic counterfactual. Hover to see exact values at each year.
Treatment effects (gap between actual and synthetic debt-to-GDP) with p-values. Hover to see exact values and significance levels.

After 1991, Guatemala’s debt-to-GDP falls sharply while the synthetic remains elevated, producing an average gap of approximately −15 percentage points. Significance strengthens in later periods, reaching the 1% level from 2001 through 2003.

The key contribution is disentangling the mechanism. Central bank debt fell from $0.9 billion to $0.1 billion (the rule bound on its target), but total external debt actually increased from $2.6 billion to $3.3 billion. The government shifted borrowing to non-central-bank sources. The debt-to-GDP improvement came primarily because nominal GDP nearly tripled, driven by 123% cumulative inflation, and surging remittances ($130M to $563M) allowed for a controlled and slow depreciation.

The lesson: narrow fiscal rules can bind on their specific target, but do not guarantee broader discipline. Governments substitute toward other borrowing channels, and improving ratios can mask rising absolute debt when inflation outpaces new borrowing. Comprehensive frameworks covering total borrowing may be necessary for genuine fiscal consolidation.